Review: “Forte”
Ben McLaughlin agreed to do this review over a year ago, and we were too slack to post it up. Nevertheless, it seems pertinent to put it up now and revisit one of the more recent pipe band CDs to be released. So, enjoy Ben’s review of the 2012 Forte concert put on by the 2012 European and Cowal Champions, the Boghall and Bathgate Caledonia Pipe Band.
Boghall & Bathgate – Review
Pipe band CD’s can define a generation. Not only do they provide hours of entertainment for the experienced amongst us, but they can also serve as motivation for the youngsters who aspire to one day witness, or in the case of our very own Liam Kernaghan, play as a member of such a legendary pipe band.
It is with this in mind that I take great pleasure in being able to review Boghall & Bathgate’s latest CD, ‘Forte’.
This recording was done in a very special year for the band affectionately referred to as ‘the Boggies’. In 2012 they won both the European & Cowal Championships ahead of what many consider to be the most competitive field in recent memory. This band is a force to be reckoned with, no question!
Pressing play for the first time, I was intrigued as to what I would hear, as I had never actually heard Boghall outside of the competition arena.
From the very first track, two things are clear:
- This band loves to produce bright, rich tone; and
- They play a distinctive style that oozes musical appreciation and excellence.
To be fair, by its’ very nature, when recording a live concert, there are going to be a couple of things that don’t quick click on the night. For me, there were a small number of instances where note errors, finishes and some blowing inconsistencies detract from the potential that a clean run would produce. I say this, because when you start knocking off bands such as Field Marshall Montgomery, you’re going to be compared to your competitors each time you play.
In saying that, there are many aspects of this recording that appeal. The tunes themselves are expertly arranged with harmonies that compliment the grooving nature of the presentation; the drum corps consistently showcases why they were the 2012 Champion of Champions; and the backing band is absolutely top class.
My favourite track would have to be the Journey to the Centre of the Celts. This track has a really smooth groove to it, played on excellent tonal bagpipes with subtle, effective accompaniment from the backing instruments. Perfect to put on in the background on a lazy Sunday afternoon.
What are my overall impressions?
Clearly a top tier grade 1 band on display with touches of class all the way through the CD.
Entertainment value?
Absolutely.
How high quality is it?
If you put your critical judging ears on you’ll pick up some things, but that’s only because of the overall level being so high.
Would I purchase it?
Yes.
